Showing posts with label Occupy wall street. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Occupy wall street. Show all posts

Sunday, March 18, 2012

Is "Occupy Wall Street" movement a fraud?

Amazing news item in today's local San Jose Mercury News about definition of poverty in US and comparing it to rest of the world. Here are some striking facts about it:

 - As per US definition of "Poverty" family of four which makes less than $22K per year is poor
 - Fifteen percent of US population falls under this so called poverty line
 - This is all time high
 - Average income in Thailand is half of the poverty line definition of US
 - Poland's average income is almost same as US poverty line
 - India's average income is almost two third of US poverty line

Bottom line, Eighty (80) percent of world population lives below US poverty line standards. In US, anyone who can be qualified as "poor" as per US definition is eligible for safety net (Social Security, Medi-Care, food stamps etc..).

Doesn't this makes joke of this so called "Occupy Wall Street" movement.. These people better should spend their energy and resources to help rest of the world's eighty percent population. But why should they? that is not their problem.. and exactly that attitude makes them US a common target of hatred and animosity. Though this is general perception, I still feel it is more of jealousy. I know I am writing something which lot of people won't like.. but in my view that is the fact. US standard of living are higher than rest of the world and they have worked hard in past to build infrastructure and system for which they are reaping rewards. US has full right to define own standards of poverty.

Ultimately it is all relative.. Isn't it? I take India's example of poverty. Every time I visit standards of living are going up and so is definition of poverty. Which is exactly relative to progress made by the nation.. Though, I must admit that there must be many part or section of people who are still in same condition and progress hasn't reached them for a while. But it will percolate to all parts of society and population.

Having seen poverty standards of India .. Coming back to US. I feel all the charity work here is a joke. Personally I feel that there shouldn't be any need of charitable organizations in US. The level of progress and development makes it a joke out of charity here. In US focus should be to create jobs for these unemployed people. That will have much bigger impact than distributing wealth as charity. Jobs growth will enable government and other organizations to take care of so called poor and some really disadvantaged people.

But then, same is true for rest of the world.. Isn't it.. I am listening to slogan like "Gareebi hatao" (remove poverty) since my childhood in India.. Did it removed or made any progress. Instead it just created more corrupt society and enabled richer get even more richer by this social net. What if spending billions of dollars for this, we would have spent it on infrastructure to enable ease of business and creation of production facility.. that would have definitely made difference. Which is still true..

Well this discussion is endless.. but give it a thought and let me know your views..

====================



THE GLOBALIST QUIZ

Where do poor Americans rank globally?

The weekly quiz is provided by the Globalist, a daily online feature service that covers issues and trends in globalization. The nonpartisan organization provides commercial services and nonprofit educational features.

QUESTION



The Occupy Wall Street movement brought a fresh focus to poverty and income distribution in the United States. According to recent Census Bureau numbers, about 15 percent of Americans live below the poverty line, the highest percentage in 18 years. But how does U.S. poverty compare in a global context? We wonder: The Americans whose income is just low enough to be classified as poor, according to U.S. standards, are still better-off than …

ANSWER


A.
About 22 percent of the world population

B.
About half of the world population

C.
About 65 percent of the world population

D.
About 80 percent of the world population

A.
About 22 percent of the world population is not correct.

Those among the poorest 22 percent of the world’s population are incredibly poor by U.S. standards.

They are the 1.3 billion people who, according to new World Bank data, have incomes below what the World Bank designates as the absolute poverty line: $1.25 per day — or roughly $450 per year. There are just no such poor people in the United States. Although U.S.

poverty thresholds are differentiated by gender, age, place of residence, and other criteria, the average poverty line for a “typical” household of four is $22,400 annually. This works out as a little over $15 per day per person — or 12 times higher than the World Bank absolute poverty line.

B.
About half of the world population is

not correct.


People exactly in the middle of the global income distribution have incomes of less than $1,500 a year per person (adjusted for purchasing power), or just a bit over $4 per day. This is close to the average level of income in countries such as Cambodia and the Philippines.

Again, there are no such poor people in the United States or in the rest of the rich world.

C.
About 65 percent of the world population is not correct.

People who are near the 65th percentile by income in the world make about $2,800 a year per person (also adjusted for purchasing power). This is the average income level of people in Thailand. There are indeed some among the very poor in the United States whose incomes are about that level.

They are considered “extra poor” by U.S.

standards.

D.
About 80 percent of the world population is correct.

The income of those who are just sufficiently “bad off” to be considered poor in the United States is about $5,600 a year per person (or $22,400 for a fourperson household).

This is slightly less than the average income in Poland, and it makes these Americans better- off than about 80 percent of the world population, according to economist Branko Milanovic, author of a recent book on global income distribution, “The Haves and the Have-Nots.” The poorest Americans benefit from a social safety net that the vast majority of the world’s poor must do without.

Sunday, November 13, 2011

Occupy Wall Street movement and Class War in America

I still can't completely understand reasons for Occupy Wall Street movement. Only reason I can guess is "Frustration"!!! This is the only way people are expressing their frustration against Wall Street Companies and their "Excessive salaries and bonus" for their executives and top employees.. On top of that, the very same companies were bailed out by their own "People's Government" by their tax money... and same people were left behind by their own government.. That way it seems to be valid frustration!!!!

"Excessive"? Really? It is debatable..

Wall street argues back by saying that they have returned all the money with interest (zero percent?) back to government already. If they wouldn't have got government money common people would have even worse condition as they claim it would have create mayhem in main street companies as well.. (Well, if you do fraud, you do it so big that it will kill everyone around you not just you.. So government instead of punishing you should come and rescue you!!).

Moreover, Wall street is wide open to any one with talent and passion to work hard.. Most of these bankers are not their because their Dad or Mom are top officials of the company.. they are there because of their talent and hard work in Schools or elsewhere or somewhere.. it is wide open to everyone.. even to people who are spending time in these so called Occupy Wall Street movement.. Nobody is saying no or stopping these guys/gals to go and work for wall street and make millions.. it is their choice, they can waste their time here or do something which will help their career and help them come out of this situation...

Then there is big discussion going on about so called "Class War".. All thanks to Flat Tax rate war initiated by Republican Presidential Candidates.. On top of that.. report came out few days back that top Five percent rich people got even more richer and bottom poor people got even more poorer.. Essentially, divide between  rich and poor is getting bigger and bigger.
How about overall standards of living for everyone.. have they gone up? I guess that they have gone up for majority of US citizens... though rate of change has been different for a different class.. It was definitely more for top income group simply because of world economy is more integrated.. If you are rich and little bit of interested in making money, you will take advantage of each part of world to make you even more richer..Where as bottom 5% of population, this benefit needs to percolate thru these Extra Rich and Rich folks.. Hence we have this wider gap in class and resulting so called class war..

However, the fact we might be missing is, that there is no certainty that this top five percent class is same over last couple of decades.. this class, especially in United States is pretty much dynamic and it is not hereditary or dynasty like it is still in many parts of the world.. Many of the billionaires are self made who were not even part of this list twenty or thirty years back.. That is the beauty of this system here. It is free and available to everyone.. If you have passion to become rich you will be rich.. you will figure out innovative ways to do so if you want to..  and with little luck and lot of hard work you will be part of this category, irrespective of the fact if your parents are lowest 5% or middle class or top 5%.. doesn't matter..

As far as Taxes are concerned.. there are different issues.. like top One percent income people pays forty or sixty percent of all the taxes.. and bottom forty or sixty percent literally don't pay any income tax.. Now how fair it is from rich guys perspective to tax them further..

At the same time under current situation any more tax burden on lower middle class or any discontinuation of benefit to lower middle class will look way too in-humane.. at least under current circumstances.. Also, lower middle class spends almost all of their income so they in-fact pay higher consumption or sales tax in ratio of their income.. Whereas rich hardly pay any consumption tax as compared to their income..

To me, under current circumstances, it feels like that we should leave current tax structure as it is.. when economy improves and has stable growth, increase tax slowly across the board to cover the massive deficit we are facing. Moreover, I totally disagree that you can spur growth by cutting tax or giving more short term benefits to employers.. If you want real growth then you need to set up proper environment, infrastructure and mode of society so that employers can be confident of growth.. Even if they have to pay few pennies here and there on these taxes they will hire people if they see growth.. They won't if they aren't confident of it whether you give them any amount of tax rebates..

Tuesday, November 8, 2011

President Clinton's new book "Back to Work"

I have always been fan of President Clinton and his books. This new book also seems to be good read. Going to get it soon... Watched him on TV after long time and his talk do make lot of sense. I guess, President Obama better listen to him on housing and other fixes he is suggesting to fix economy.

Totally agree with his views on Occupy Wall street movement. In America we never resent or envy other's success. That is the best part of this country. You get success and make millions or whatever amount in bonuses solely based on your talent and hard work. There is no dynasty to inherit and continue making money. Wall Street is wide open for any one who has talent and zeal to work hard. Instead of wasting time in these kind of movement, you are better off working hard and make some positive contributions to world.