Showing posts with label environment. Show all posts
Showing posts with label environment. Show all posts

Saturday, September 28, 2013

and we are still debating about Net Metering..

In my view, this is simply hoax being created by Utility Companies in advance to protect slide in their business in long term. Solar panel based electricity production is dampening their growth in short term and in long term going to kill them.. They are starting all this noise so these net metering could be killed and solar panels become un-attractive for future home owners. They know for sure that solar panel prices are continue to fall and within 5-10-20 years, they will become norm at each house.

Here is my take on why net metering is valid and in fact not only eligible for retail rate but in my view even higher prices then retail. Here are some of thoughts on this:


  •  Solar Panels usually produce maximum when we have peak demand and help reduce peak demand of the grid. Utilities maintain specific peakers (small power plant or additional capacity in power plants) which they can get rid of or at least reduce capacity
  • Regarding this talk about retail Vs wholesale price paid for electricity pumped back to grid by homeowners - this electricity is produced right next to the consumption point.. theoretically, your next door neighbor might be consuming the additional electricity generated by solar panels. It is not that this power is bloody going back to power station traversing all the transformers and grid.. NO.. It just uses few meters of the power cables and it gets consumed right next door.. It actually takes out the stress of grid and in a way help elongate life of the equipment. Reducing their failures and thus reducing their maintenance costs.. In a way it reduces overall transmission and distribution losses incurred while transporting electricity from central power plants to your home. In my view, they should be paid more than retail price!! and this is no joke..  even utility companies knows the value of this distributed generation.. 
There can be hundreds of more logical reasons be listed in favor of these solar panels.. there is no end to this discussion.. Ultimately , they are good for consumers and they are good for  environment.. It is definitely not good for utilities in long run.. However, utilities need to decide, whether they want to die gracefully or they want to die in anguish and pain.. moreover, they are not going to die completely any how.. at least in 30-50 years for sure.. there role could become infrastructure service provider instead of providing electricity itself..


‘NET METERING’

Analysis says solar will carry high cost


Industry battles news that nonusers may pay $1.1B per year by 2020


By Dana Hull


 


A long-awaited analysis of “net metering,” the policy that allows homeowners, school districts and businesses to offset the cost of their electric use with the rooftop solar power they generate and export to the grid, finds the policy will cost California’s nonsolar customers $1.1 billion a year by 2020.

The lengthy “California Net Energy Metering Evaluation,” released Thursday by the California
 Public Utilities Commission, will strongly influence discussions among state regulators about how to restructure electric rates.
The solar industry is already crying foul, saying the study design was stacked against solar. Others say it’s time for net metering to be overhauled.

“There’s no question that there’s a subsidy to solar customers,” said Marcel Hawiger of TURN, the Utility Reform Network. “Net metering was a policy designed to jump-start the solar industry in California, but it’s not a sustainable policy.”

Large utilities like PG&E have a four-tiered rate system: The more electricity you use, the more you pay. Tier 1 customers pay 13.2 cents a kilowatt hour for electricity, while at Tier 4 it’s 35.1 cents. The tiered rate structure has been a big driver of rooftop solar in California, since many homeowners who go solar do so to cut down on high monthly 
bills. Solar customers are reimbursed for the electricity they generate and export to the grid at the retail rate.

Utilities have argued that under the current rate structure, customers using net metering do not pay their fair share of the costs of the transmission and distribution grid. And since solar customers tend to be more affluent,
 utilities argue that lower-income, nonsolar ratepayers are subsidizing solar customers.

The solar industry is already fighting back against the report, noting solar is increasingly being adopted by middle-income consumers, creates jobs for installers and that everyone benefits from “avoided costs,” or the need for utilities to build additional power plants.

“The study design was stacked against solar,” said Susannah Churchill, solar policy director at Vote Solar, a solar advocacy
 group in San Francisco. “To do a cost-benefit analysis and not include benefits like public health and jobs just inflates utility claims. Rooftop solar is a threat to the utility business model, and they are doing everything possible to stop its momentum.”

The report, by the San Francisco- based consulting group E3, found that most homeowners who have solar systems are high energy users with an average household income of $91,000, well above the state average of $54,000, and that the savings
 that solar customers achieve on their own bills is shifted to other ratepayers who must make up the difference.

PG&E has more than 93,000 customers on net metering and adds roughly 2,000 more each month at a pace that, from a utility perspective, is not financially sustainable.

“PG&E has long supported solar for its environmental benefits,” said spokeswoman Lynsey Paulo. “We are the largest buyer of solar energy in the nation, and lead the nation in the number of customers
 who have installed solar on their rooftops. We look forward to working with lawmakers, regulators, industry and our customers to chart a path to a bright and sustainable solar future.”

E3 will present the results of the NEM study in the PUC auditorium at 505 Van Ness Ave., San Francisco, on Friday, and is accepting public comments until
 Oct. 10.

Contact Dana Hull at 408-920-2706. Follow her at Twitter.com/danahull.

Friday, July 13, 2012

Good Apple!!

Seems that our barge of criticism like this:

http://shaigarg.blogspot.com/2012/07/bad-apple.html

did worked and all these BOTs collecting and gauging feel and pulse of web did worked. Important thing is Apple listened. Even though everyone was saying that they will still buy Apple but are unhappy with their decision.

God Job everyone!!

Cheers!!

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702304373804577525033302381546.html?mod=djemTEW_h


Apple Inc. AAPL +1.01% said it was re-registering its products with a voluntary registry of green electronics, reversing course after a flood of criticism.
Apple, in an open letter from Bob Mansfield, the company's senior vice president of hardware engineering, said the company would relist its products on the U.S. government-backed registry, called Epeat, potentially putting an end to the controversy that led at least one city government to tell its employees no longer to purchase the Cupertino, Calif., company's products as a result.
Earlier this month, The Wall Street Journal reported that Apple had requested its 39 desktop and laptop computers, as well as its monitors, be removed from the list of environmentally friendly products. At the time, Epeat said Apple had told it that the company's designs were no longer consistent with the registry's requirements.
The Epeat standard was created in collaboration between government agencies, activist groups and manufacturers, including Apple. Epeat-certified devices are considered to have been designed with higher energy efficiency and for ease of use in recycling.
Earlier this week, San Francisco's Department of the Environment said it would send out a letter over the coming weeks informing all the city's 50 agencies that Apple's laptops and desktops would "no longer qualify" for purchase with city funds. The city said it is mandatory policy that city funds only be used to purchase Epeat-certified computers. The federal government, as well, requires that 95% of its laptops and desktops be Epeat-certified.
In his letter, Mr. Mansfield defended Apple's efforts to make its devices "the most environmentally responsible products in our industry, and that much of the company's progress isn't yet measured by the Epeat standard. But, he admitted, customers clearly were concerned about the company's continued involvement in the registry.
"We've recently heard from many loyal Apple customers who were disappointed to learn that we had removed our products from the Epeat rating system," he said. "I recognize that this was a mistake."
Apple said its relationship with Epeat has become stronger as a result of this experience, and that it will continue to work with the rating system.
Apple shares recently rose 1.2% to $605.71.
--Jessica E. Vascellaro contributed to this report

Tuesday, July 10, 2012

BAD Apple :-(

Will leaving EPEAT impact Apple? May be.. May be not.. This will be interesting.. let us see if people love design and form-factor or their mother nature.. I am sure Apple will come with some better explanation and may be better environment friendly option while they ditch EPEAT logo.

In short term, it is not making any difference. If you look into details, looks like, they knew that iPad/iPhone is not going to be approved which is one of the big business segment for them.. So why not ditch it completely.. May be plant some trees somewhere else to offset this logo?









GLUED-IN BATTERIES AT ISSUE

Uproar ripens as Apple turns less ‘green’


Tech leader’s pullout from registry of eco-friendly products spurs backlash


By Dana Hull and John Boudreau


Staff writers


After establishing itself as an environmental leader among consumer electronics companies, Apple’s abrupt withdrawal from a
 prominent “green” product registry has set off a furor in the blogosphere and could modestly cut into the company’s computer sales.

Apple’s decision may be tied to the design of the new Mac-Book Pros, which have batteries glued into the case and can’t be disassembled for recycling — a violation of the green certification standards of EPEAT, a nonprofit
 product rating group backed by many manufacturers and the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.
“I’ve had some conversations, and Apple has said that their design direction is not compatible with EPEAT standards,” the group’s CEO, Robert Frisbee, in an interview Monday. “It’s kind of odd since they've helped design” the standards. 


Greenpeace spokesman Casey Harrell said Apple “has pitted design against the environment — and chosen design. They’re making a big bet that people don’t care, but recycling is a big issue.” 

Harrell described the Cupertino company’s withdrawal from EPEAT as “unfortunate,” noting that Apple in the past has introduced eco-friendly design features such as using aluminum instead of plastic in the casings of their products, which makes recycling easier. 

Apple has often boasted that its computers and laptops achieve “gold ratings” from EPEAT on its environmental reports. It’s withdrawal will eliminate numerous products — 39 laptops, desktop computers and monitors — from the well-known green registry. 

Apple’s decision has flummoxed cities like San Francisco, which can no longer buy Apple computers because its procurement rules require EPEAT approval. 

“I don’t know why Apple would choose to go this route. It’s really bad for EPEAT, and it’s really bad for anyone trying to do green purchasing,” said Chris Geiger, the city of San Francisco’s toxics reduction coordinator. “We strongly believe that eco-labels are essential for green purchasing, and Apple just withdrew from the list. We want to register our displeasure and urge Apple to reconsider.” 

To meet EPEAT standards, products must be easy to disassemble into separate components by recyclers. Companies like Apple, Dell, Hewlett-Packard and Samsung have participated in developing the organization’s standards, and EPEAT’s registry of products has long been a green procurement guide of sorts for the federal government, cities, large corporations and colleges and universities. 

Apple has offered no explanation for why it would glue the batteries into the new MacBook Pros or in other ways make its products difficult to disassemble, but the company has a long history of designing products to discourage tinkering by their users. 

It notified EPEAT of its withdrawal in a letter Thursday, but didn’t elaborate on its reasons. An Apple representative Monday declined to comment, saying only that the company remains committed to the environment. 

Based in Portland, Ore., EPEAT is a nonprofit organization funded by major PC manufacturers and the EPA that awards electronic products a stamp of approval if they meet the group’s minimum requirements for energy efficiency, use of toxic materials and disposal. 

Apple was long criticized by Greenpeace and other groups for failing to eliminate hazardous materials from products. But it eventually became a leader among tech companies for eliminating toxic chemicals from its computers. Still, it has faced criticism from Greenpeace for allegedly being slow to abandon coalpowered energy for its everexpanding server farms. 

EPEAT standards do not currently cover smartphones or tablet computers, which represent a fastgrowing portion of Apple’s business. But standards for those products are being crafted, Frisbee said, hinting that Apple’s phenomenally successful iPad may not be in compliance. 

“There’s an issue with the cementing in of batteries on the iPad,” he said. “If you can’t separate the toxics from recyclables, it doesn’t qualify. Other manufacturers have been able to find ways to stay within the EPEAT requirements. It’s a little confusing as to why Apple, which has always been the leader, has chosen a different direction.” 

Barbara Kyle, the national coordinator of the Electronics TakeBack Coalition, a San Franciscobased group that promotes green design and recycling of electronics products, also wondered if Apple was withdrawing from EPEAT because its new products cannot be easily disassembled. 

“What does a recycler do? The first thing is they take apart the product to remove the hazardous stuff. They absolutely need to be able to open it up,” Kyle said. “If you can’t even take the battery out, or if you’ve glued in the battery with industrial strength glue, that is not designing with recycling in mind.” 

Gartner analyst Van Baker said Apple’s pullout from EPEAT will have little impact on its bottom line. He added that Apple has good “environmental credibility” for a consumer electronics company. 

“Let’s face it, the EPEAT label is pretty far down the purchase criteria list for most people,” Baker said. “I’m sure Apple will point to other things, such as the fact all the materials they use are free of any pollution.” 

Contact Dana Hull at 408920-2706. Follow her at Twitter.com/danahull. 




Saturday, December 24, 2011

Foxconn entring into solar - Is it a good news or??

Looks like FOXCONN.. Contract manufacturing giant is getting into Solar Modules.. Knowing FOXCONN.. it is definitely a bad news for all the Industrial giants (even existing Chinese manufacturers) and even worse news for US based manufacturers.. Foxconn is known to be working on volumes with very low margin.. on top of that they have optimized their manufacturing beyond original Japanese manufacturer's dreams..

On second thoughts, US manufacturers or I should say, US Solar companies or even startups in Solar areas can easily get into solar big time.. They can probably hire or contract solar manufacturing to Foxconn, based on their new designs and innovations.. thereby greatly increasing innovation and efficiency of Sola Panels further.. So, as usual, US companies will benefit from it.. employees may not as much unless, you are into fewer high end design/R&D jobs..

However, it is definitely GREAT news for most of the consumers and for green technology. It shows that there is great promise ahead for green technology and very soon Solar Energy will become mainstream.. Way we buy TV/Game-consoles/iPhones.. we will start getting solar panels for our home and start upgrading them as they improve their efficiency... This should drastically reduce emissions and and hence green house gases and hence improve our next generation's future prospects!!! (I agree.. that was tooo much for such a small news.. but then who knows, my news analysis/prediction may turn out true!!!)



FOXCONN Entry into solar may push down prices

Foxconn Technology’s decision to start making solar power modules may speed the rate at which margins are narrowing for Chinese manufacturers, another blow for an industry already coping with a plunge in prices. The Taiwanese company that’s the world’s biggest contract maker of electronics including Apple’s iPhone has started work on a solarmodule plant in China’s eastern province of Jiangsu. “Foxconn plans to build new factories with undreamed- of scale and lower cost,” Jenny Chase, who leads a team of six solar analysts at Bloomberg New Energy Finance, said. “It will push capacity higher and prices lower.” Prices for solar cells have skidded 62 percent this year as Chinese companies led by Suntech boosted production and won market share from European and Japanese rivals.